Call it what you will: a rehashing, a renewing, a reimagining or a revival, Cygnet’s last show at The Theatre in Old Town, “Oklahoma” by Rogers and Hammerstein II, still has the original Hammerstein lyrics and Rogers’ book and music. What’s different is it brings out a darker, oft more modern take on our star crossed lovers of Oklahoma, Curly and Laurey.
Cowboy Curly McLain (Michael Louis Cusimano last seen on Cygnet’s stage in “Natasha, Pierre” in 2024), is one hell of a handsome leading man with vocals and smooth guitar playing.
![]() |
Ariella Kvashny and Michael Louis Cusimano |
He and Kvashny (Laurey), who make beautiful music together, (“People Will Say We’re In Love”) have this on again off again relationship, but it’s clear she only has eyes for Curly even though she flirts with hired hand, Jud Fry, (Jacob Caltrider), a misfit in both the cowman and farmer’s world. It’s a three way relationship that can only end in tragedy.
With music by Richard Rogers and book and lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein II (the first of their collaborations), the story unfolds in what was Indian Territories before Oklahoma became a state, pitting the farmers against the cowboys (“Farmer and the Cowmen”) as the basis for the big picture. (“Kansas City”, “Farmer and the Cowman”. “Oh, What a “Beautiful Mornin’” and of course “Oklahoma!” are but some of the great Rogers and Hammerstein tunes from this show that are forever etched in our collective memories.
![]() |
Paul Morgavo, Eli Wood, Jaxon Smith, Marc Caro-Willcox |
It’s tough keeping a good show down and every now and then it’s good to bring it back to the fore for some good old fashioned folk lore, lively entertainment and just plain great music. It opened on Broadway in 1943.
Director Sean Murray, swaggering in his red cowboy boots and big black cowboy hat, directs this new take on what some are calling part classic and part reimaged, in combining the old with the new. And it works, overall!
Love stories and comedy (some tongue in cheek) abound in the triangular relationships between cowboy Curly McClain and farm girl Laurie Williams and the petulant Jud Fry, and Ali Hakim, Ado Annie and Will Parker.
Based on the Lynne Riggs play “Green Grow the Lilacs”, “Oklahoma”, when it was still called Indian Territory, sails or should I say dances (Jill Gorrie choreographs this show with original choreography based on Agnes de Mille) and sings its way through one musical number after another (some seventeen).
![]() |
Jacob Caltrider |
There is darkness: In Jud’s smokehouse, where Curly seeks out Jud and taunts and teases him (“Poor Jud is Daid”) and a Dream Sequence with Laurey, who imagines the conflict within herself, recoils. (“Dream Ballet” choreographed by Jordan Miller).
There is also much lightheartedness: The silly romantic comings and goings of Ali Akim ( Ricky Bulda) and Ado Annie (Jazley Genovese (“I Caint Say No”); the on again off again romance of Curly and Laurey and the cowboy/farmer riff; the auctioning off of the goodie baskets, (“Farmer and the Cowman”).
![]() |
Company |
Eli Woods’ Will Parker shines through in every direction with his strong dancing and acting. Wood’s trips all over himself trying not to get shot by Annie’s father, Andrew (Manny Fernandes) who is doing his due diligence, shotgun in hand aimed at Will, in case Ali, the traveling salesman, (Ricky Bulda) does something to dishonor his daughter’s reputation.
![]() |
Ariella Kvashny, Michael Louis Cusimano |
Cusimano and Kvashny, where the chemistry is there and the romance rings true to form, allow the ongoing struggle between Jud Fry and Curley to reach a climax while both vie for her attention as it reaches a predictable, yet hokey take on the way the law worked then. It was interesting to watch as Aunt Eller held court. (I hate to say it, but some things never change in some states.)
![]() |
Linda Libby |
As I mentioned at the outset, this is not your run of the mill Oklahoma, where everything happens around Aunt Eller’s farm house (scenic designer Mathys Herbert). If anything, this is truly an ensemble work of art where each character has his/her own place on stage and dances, sings, and acts to the hilt.
Patrick Marion is musical director as well as playing Accordion and Mandolin. Kyle Bayquen on Bass, Erika Boras-Tesi on Cello, Sean LaPerreque on Violin/Viola, Dave Pschaida on Percussion, Cliff Thrasher on Sub Cello and Michael Reyes on Guitar/Banjo. All excel.
![]() |
Linda Libby Holding it together |
Credit Lighting designer Anne E. McMills, Sound, TJFucella, Props, Jessica Cuoto, Wigs and Makeup Peter Hermann and Zoë Trautmann, Costumes to make this one of the most ‘interesting’, ‘different’ and colorful production of an ‘oldie but goody’ that’s OK LA HOMA…OK!
See It!
See you at the theatre.
When: Runs through Aug.31st. 7 p.m. Wednesdays-Fridays; 2 and 7 p.m. Saturdays; 2 p.m. Sundays.
Where: Cygnet Theatre, 4040 Twiggs St., Old
Town San Diego
Photo: Karli Cadel
Tickets: $30 and up
Info: 619-337-1525
Online: cygnettheatre.org